My first job out of college was working as an editorial assistant for a national home décor magazine. My boss, Deborah, was a humorless workaholic who treated me like a second-class citizen. I made a whopping $18,000 a year (which, back then, seemed like a good entry level salary), so I lived at home for a while until I could save up enough cash to rent my own place. My parents, however, lived 30 miles away from my office, so my commute was a nightmare. That didn’t stop old Deborah from asking me to leave my house at an ungodly hour, visit homes to take photos and “be in the office by nine.” Because, clearly I was a woman who could move space and time.Deborah spoke to me so rudely some of the other editors closed their doors when she stood by my desk. I didn’t like her much, but I learned a lot from her. The problem was my schooling. I was taught when you had your first job you should do anything and everything asked of you, and you should do so with a smile. So imagine my surprise when the managing editor promoted me because the other editors complained on my behalf. As one editor later told me, “We said, ‘If you don’t get her away from Deborah, we’re going to take her away ourselves.’”
When I left the magazine I went to work for another tough, nose-to-the-grindstone woman. She yelled when she was angry (not so much at me, but in general) and nothing she said or did really bothered me. (She had a great sense of humor, though, which probably helped.) I remember one time she came into the room screaming about something and was so angry my assistant (who is still a good friend today) looked over at me in horror. I just shrugged and continued to work. My friend and I laugh a lot about this incident. “You weren’t fazed at all,” she said. “I, however, was shocked!”
I wasn’t affected by my boss’s tirades mainly because I grew up in a house filled with loud voices and yelling. I just thought people expressed themselves by screaming when they were upset. My parents yelled, gesticulated and made themselves heard. What’s so wrong about that, I thought. They’re just yelling.
I bring up this point because I wonder if I am having the same effect on my own kids. I don’t yell and scream the way my parents did, and I really try to keep calm as much as possible (but, hello, I am far from perfect). But I do use a stern voice and express myself when I'm angry. I’m not nearly as critical as my mom was to me, too, but I still hear myself saying things that sometimes make me cringe when the words escape my lips. When I think back to how I handled my former bosses, I also think that my crazy upbringing set the stage for success. People yell. People go off the handle. We may not mean to, and we may regret doing so, but we are human. Because I lived with people who yelled I didn’t cower and wasn’t bothered when it was done to me in the workplace. Isn’t it all right, then, to sometimes show we aren’t Stepford parents?
Well, not according to the experts. In one article I read, yelling at children teaches the opposite of what we intend. (Click here to read more). I disagree with some of what the article says but I do agree that kids need to be taught to express themselves without yelling and to do so, we need to lead by example. The article does say that yelling won’t leave indelible scars or cause irreparable psychological damage, but it is hurtful. (I think words are more hurtful than yelling. Saying in a calm voice, “You are so useless,” is much worse than screaming, “Clean up your room!”)
Yelling is especially harmful when two parents engage in a fight in front of the kids. In fact, in one study by the National Institute of Mental Health, they monitored for three years children’s behavior, attention span, ability to focus at home and at school, and how the kids perceived their parents’ relationship. They found kids who worried about their parents tended to have more problems in school and had increased risk for anxiety, depression, aggression and trouble interacting with peers. (Click here to read the article). The point? If you and your spouse have a problem, learn to discuss the issue without screaming at each other. (Click here for positive ways to argue and for what not to do when fighting in front of your children).
Despite my background I am still going to try and not yell at my kids because I admit, I didn't exactly love hearing my parents scream all the time. I can’t promise I won’t fly off the handle every so often, but I do try to keep my calm when I can. Yet I do believe that hearing a person get loud once in a while (especially when we apologize for our bad behavior) allows a child to see we’re all human and we all make mistakes. And if they happen to get a boss who is a screamer, at least they won’t be as affected as someone who grew up in a home akin to The Waltons.
(If your child is the one who screams, click here to read advice on how to teach your child to deal with his or her temper.)
Photo by Colin Adamson, courtesy of stock.xchng
























